Zero-Sum Airwaves: Why Political Advertisements Are Legally Allowed to Deceive You

Zero-Sum Airwaves: Why Political Advertisements Are Legally Allowed to Deceive You

Zero-Sum Airwaves: Why Political Advertisements Are Legally Allowed to Deceive You

Zero-Sum Airwaves: Why Political Advertisements Are Legally Allowed to Deceive You

by Jessica Fike

“Taxpayer-funded benefits for illegal immigrants. That’s Sherrod Brown’s Plan…Sherrod Brown tried to eliminate Veterans’ healthcare benefits,” an ad financed by the Senate Leadership Fund (SLF) — an independent super PAC solely dedicated to protecting and expanding the Republican Senate Majority — claims in a flagrant falsification attempt.

The ad references H.R. 676, a 2005 universal healthcare bill co-sponsored by Brown that aimed to provide comprehensive healthcare insurance to all eligible U.S. residents — employing an aggressive tactic called zero-sum framing, a cognitive and communicative perspective where one person’s gain directly correlates to another’s loss. The SLF deliberately manufactures an artificial choice between two unrelated issues: veterans and “illegals,” with the ad contending that the bill was an attempt by Brown to prioritize illegal immigrants at the expense of veterans — a gross decontextualization of H.R. 676.

The truth, however, is a far more nuanced, positive-sum matter, as both immigrants and veterans were concurrently covered by the language of the bill, with Brown later voting to expand veterans’ healthcare significantly through the Sergeant First Class Heath Robinson Honoring our Promise to Address Comprehensive Toxics (PACT) Act. According to the Federal Budget, the bipartisan legislation named after SFC Heath Robinson — a Central Ohio soldier who died of a rare lung cancer at age 39 after exposure to burn pits in Iraq — “expands and extends eligibility for VA health care veterans with toxic exposures. It applies to veterans of the Vietnam, Gulf War, and post-9/11 eras.”

If the Senate Leadership Fund’s ad is just a mechanism of distortion, sum-framing gimmicks, and omissions of the truth, then why is it allowed to publicly broadcast on television? Evidently, if a pharmaceutical company did much of the same, selectively omitting the most significant risks of a drug, the Federal Trade Commission would be sure to pull it immediately.

Structural Immunity: Judicial Scrutiny and the Deregulation of Deception

Political speech, by any standard, is the most protected form of speech under the First Amendment, warranting the highest level of scrutiny against the laws that seek to regulate it. This protection was demonstrated in the infamous 2010 Citizens United v. Federal Elections Commission case, in which the Supreme Court struck down the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act’s (BCRA) limits on independent political spending by corporations and labor unions, citing the First Amendment as a matter of rationale. Section 441b of the BCRA — prohibiting outside corporations and labor unions from using their general treasury funds to launch television ads within 60 days of the general election (or within 30 days of the primary) — failed to withstand such scrutiny, the court reasoning that the government cannot curb the political speech of corporations just because they are corporations and not individuals.

In the state of Ohio, the scrutiny threshold has been set to an impossibly high legal presumption, solidified by the 6th U.S. Court of Appeals decision in the 2016 landmark case, Susan B. Anthony List v. Driehaus.

For 42 years, Section 3517.21 (B) of the Ohio Revised Code criminalized the posting, publishing, distribution, and generalized dissemination of false statements concerning a candidate or ballot initiative, whether knowingly or with “reckless disregard.” However, as the Courthouse News Service emphasizes, “An anti-abortion group called the Susan B. List filed suit when it ran afoul of the law in 2010 with its plans to criticize then-congressman Steven Driehaus for supporting President Obama’s healthcare law.” The group had previously bought billboard space for a hyperbolic advertisement that would have equated Driehaus’s vote to a vote for taxpayer-funded abortion; the group complained that an attorney for the anti-abortion Democrat kept the billboard from going up.

Applying the strict scrutiny standards set by federal precedent, the court unanimously found that the law was not narrowly tailored to achieve the state’s interest in promoting fair elections — lacking an adequate screening process for frivolous political complaints. The court alleged that the election law failed to limit its prohibition to material statements, or in other words, statements with an actual relevancy, ability to influence, and cause harm. Judge R. Guy Cole, writing for the three-judge panel, stated, "Influencing an election by lying about a political candidate’s shoe size or vote on whether to continue a congressional debate is just as actionable as lying about a candidate’s party affiliation or vote on an important policy issues, such as the Affordable Care Act.”

Beyond the courtroom, federal broadcast architecture adds another layer of immunity. Notwithstanding political speech’s almost inviolable, shielded status, Section 315 of the rules set by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) explicitly prohibits broadcasters from exercising censorship over the content of candidate-sponsored political advertisements. Thus, even if the material in these ads is blatantly libelous, defamatory, or falsified, local broadcast stations (ABC, CBS, NBC affiliates) cannot legally block, edit, or alter them — without risking broadcast license revocation or other FCC penalties.

The Political Economy of Airwaves: Super PACs and the Profitability of Complacency

While Section 315 of the FCC rules grants candidate-sponsored advertisements absolute censorship immunity, the same protections are not afforded to third-party groups or Super PACs, such as the Senate Leadership Fund. Television networks and private digital platforms, therefore, have the legal right to reject ads that contain defamatory material, libelous slander, or other egregiously false information.

However, the credibility of such ads is, oftentimes, not a priority for broadcast stations that amass significant, lucrative revenue gain. “There is no limit on how much the stations can charge Super PACs and dark-money groups for ads. And no one can blame these stations for being eager to rake in the big bucks from these cash cows,” the Campaign Legal Center emphasizes in their article, “TV Stations on Political Ads: Take the Money and Run.”

Ultimately, with the architectural frameworks of the law, the media sphere’s complacency, and the government unable to act as “arbiters of the truth,” the burden of dissecting the validity of these ads lies with members of the public themselves. In keeping with the integrity of American Democracy, Ohio voters and voters in general ought to use a discerning eye — being aware of fallacy, psychological manipulation, and downright dystopian-esque propaganda.

The official high school branch of the Democratic National Commitee

Our Address

  • hsda@hsdems.org

© 2026 HSDA. All Rights Reserved